David Aho
Jim Kessinger
Jon Sanchez
Oscar Rosado
Ralph Cardona
Michael Moody
Christopher Kochan
Christopher Kohnke
Patti Joseph
Sammy Montero
Michael "Ginger" Koch
Billy Looper
Keith Oswald
Rebecca Evans
Tim Henriety
Bob Hagen
Dave Litty
George Kissinger (2)
John Petersohn
Ric Strong
1 - A League Founder
2 - A member of the NAGAAA Hall of Fame
3 - A member of the Big Apple Softball League Hall of Fame
4 - A member of the ASANA Hall of Fame
John "Jack" Smith (2023)
George Wentzler (2012)
Georgie's Alibi (2012)
Robert Tinker (2011)
Dennis Manieri (2009)
Juanita "Miss Nita" Helie (2008)
Jason McDonnold (2007)
Ronnie Piecko (2005)